MARLA'S
MUSINGS
. . . from the Publisher of Brill's Mutual Funds
Interactive®
Click
here
for other Musings
Jump Start Your
401(k) Plan
by
Marla Brill
Publisher, Brill’s Mutual Funds Interactive
Over
the last decade, 401(k) plans have grown from a little-known section
in the tax code to the plan that millions of Americans will depend on
for retirement security. It represents the largest chunk of money many
employees have, as well as a critical source of retirement income in
the future.
Despite their popularity, evidence suggests that
people often invest in ways that might leave them searching the sofa
pillows for spare change when they retire. Experts pinpoint three main
problems:
1. Gravitating to conservative investments.
Many people continue to pour money in very conservative, low-yielding
investments such as guaranteed investment contacts, or GICs. Under a
GIC, sometimes called a stable value fund, an insurance company
guarantees payment of a set rate of interest over a specified period
of time.
According to a recent survey by Buck
Consultants, a benefits consulting firm, 62 percent of companies offer
some form of stable value fund as an investment option. At these
companies, participants have an average of over 28 percent of assets
invested there.
"Many people make the mistake of equating
conservative investing with safe investing," says, Dee Lee, a
Harvard, MA financial planner and author of The Complete Idiot’s
Guide To 401(k) Plans (Macmillan). "But conservative
investments often earn less, so you lose out over the long run to
inflation."
Squeezing out just a couple of extra percentage
points in return through more aggressive investing can make a big
difference over time. Someone who contributes $100 a month to a 401(k)
account earning 10 percent, for example, could expect to retire with
$227,933 after 30 years. If the account earned 7 percent, the nest egg
would grow to $122,709.
2. Being wedded to company stock. Many
public companies match employee contributions with company stock.
Individuals who work for such companies who also allocate much of
their voluntary contributions to their employer’s shares can easily
find the lion’s share of their 401(k) plan invested in their
employer.
With the stock market bull blessing so many
companies with good fortune over the last few years, some participants
might feel satisfied with the strategy. But those who work for stock
market laggards, such as Digital or Wang, probably don’t feel as
fortunate. And loading up on employer shares could backfire if your
company’s stock plunges into a prolonged downturn.
3. Lack of diversification. "People
typically invest in just a couple of mutual fund options, regardless
of the number of funds they have available to them," says Richard
Koski, a principal with Buck Consultants. "And they rarely spread
their choices across a broad spectrum of asset classes. The most
common choices are typically a bond fund and a balanced fund, or a
bond fund and an index fund."
Employees generally ignore investment options
that are even a little out of the mainstream. International funds, for
example, draw only six percent of 401(k) assets are at companies
offering that option. . Emerging markets funds often attract much less
than that.
"Companies have been criticized for not
offering a variety of investment choices," says Koski. "But
plan administrators often finds it too expensive and cumbersome to
offer more exotic options, such as a commodities or emerging markets
fund, when few people are likely to choose them anyway."
An Improving Picture
Avoiding such mistakes, and giving some thought
to your 401(k) investment strategy, can a big difference in account
growth over the long run. Fortunately, 401(k) investors have more
opportunities than ever to assemble a well-rounded retirement
portfolio.
Once skimpy investment menus have fattened.
Employees have an average of eight 401(k) investment options to choose
from, up from 6.3 in 1995 and 4.5 in 1993, says benefits consulting
firm Hewitt Associates. While that may pale in comparison to the
thousands of choices available to investors in IRAs or other
non-employer retirement plans, it should be enough for most people to
get the diversification they need.
The selection of investment choices varies
widely from company to company. Most offer somewhere between five and
nine options, which often include a GIC, money market fund, bond fund,
employer stock, and one or more equity mutual funds.
Two fund options that have emerged recently that
offer a broader universe of options are a mutual fund window and
self-directed brokerage accounts. A mutual fund window provides access
to all the funds in one or more mutual fund families. A self-directed
brokerage account, similar to a mutual fund window, offers a selection
of both mutual funds and individual stocks.
Flexibility has also increased. Nearly
two-thirds of employers allow employees to transfer existing balances
between investment funds on a daily basis, up from 41 percent in 1995.
If you’re looking for some kind of guidance on
how to invest your plan, it’s easier to find today than it was three
years ago . That guidance is far from comprehensive, though, and
usually takes the form group seminars, or sample asset allocation and
portfolio investing examples.
In the future, says Koski,, employees can expect
investment assistance to become more available, and more personalized.
Some companies have already hired outside advisory firms to counsel
employees over the telephone about their investment options. Employers
prefer that outsiders handle advisory work, he says, because they
don’t want to become involved in the potentially litigious area of
giving investment advice.
The Internet will also grow rapidly as an
education tool. One service, the 401(k) Forum Inc. of San Francisco,
contracts with companies to provide on-line access to investor
education tools. The service, accessible through the employer’s
intranet, solicits information about a user’s assets and tolerance
for risk. It then provides an asset allocation recommendation for
money both inside and outside of the 401(k) plan.
Allocating Your Assets
Even without such customized tools, investors
can custom-build their own portfolios. Below, financial advisor Dee
Lee provides some general asset allocation suggestions for investors
with various risk profiles:
| Investment
option |
Conservative |
Moderate |
Moderately
Aggressive |
Aggressive |
| Cash
(Money market funds) |
20% |
10% |
10% |
0% |
| Fixed
income (GICs, bond funds) |
65% |
50% |
30% |
10% |
| Stocks
or stock funds |
15% |
40% |
50% |
65% |
| Aggressive
stocks or Stock funds |
0% |
0% |
10% |
25% |
Remember that asset allocation recommendations
from mutual fund literature or guidebooks are only rough guidelines to
use to tailor to your personal situation. And traditional wisdom such
as "shift your 401(k) investments into cash as you get closer to
retirement," may not always apply, says Lee.
"Most people tend to diversify within each
account, rather than view their assets in the aggregate," she
notes. "If you have lots of money in CDs or a money market fund
outside your 401(k) plan, it’s okay to remain fairly aggressive even
when you retire, since you may not be tapping the plan for many years.
On the other hand, if a 401(k) is your only source of income, a
gradual shift to safer investments may be appropriate." Once you
retire, it’s best to use other available sources of income first to
allow your retirement plan balance to continue taking advantage of
tax-deferred compounding, she says.
Asset allocation is a continual process. As you
craft your 401(k) strategy, keep these points in mind:
Remember to rebalance.
As the markets fluctuate, you’ll need to rebalance your account at
least once a year to bring it into line with your desired asset
allocation strategy. While it may be tempting to leave your stock
market gains on the table, rather than transfer them to the more
conservative side of your investment balance sheet, spreading your
bets by rebalancing will help cushion the impact of a market downturn.
Those who don’t want to be bothered with
periodic rebalancing, or who want to have their asset allocation
decisions made for them, might consider "lifestyle funds,"
an increasingly popular choice for 401(k) plans. These funds have
preset asset allocations related to a particular investor profile,
such as conservative, moderate, or aggressive.
The main drawback of lifestyle funds is a
"wrap fee," which fund companies charge for assembling and
managing the portfolio of funds. This fee generally ranges from .5
percent to one percent of assets, and is charged in addition to
regular mutual fund expenses associated with the component funds.
Balanced funds are another popular option. These
funds maintain a fairly consistent 60/40 split of stocks to bonds, and
don’t carry a wrap fee.
Stay tough when the going gets rough.
R. Theodore Benna, President of the 401(k) Association in Cross Fork,
Pa., a consumer group, recalls how 401(k) investors bailed out of the
stock funds in droves after the October 1987 stock market crash. Ten
years later, after the Asian currency crisis hit, most of them stayed
put, he says.
"I think people are getting more
knowledgeable about investing, and the benefits of hanging in during
rough markets," says Benna. "But we haven’t tested how
people might react with a more prolonged downturn."
Ask about other investment options.
Sometimes, the mutual fund company acting as plan administrator allows
participants to occasionally purchase funds from outside the fund
family. They don’t always advertise or encourage this service,
though, so you need to ask if it’s available.
|